Saturday, February 25, 2017
Weekly ELA Blog Post #17
In this blog post I'd like to write about something I didn't get a chance to discuss before: how willing Portia was to leave Basssanio's choice up to luck. It seems odd that while she was fine using tricks to fool other suitors into choosing the wrong chest, like placing wine on top of one to tempt a suitor, dhe did no such thing to help Bassanio. Surely there were ways she could have swayed his choice towards the right chest, so the question is: did it not occur to her, or did she believe in Bassanio to choose right? While thinking about this, I realized something. It seems clear, as demonstrated throughout the story, Portia is cunning enough to get her way and not willing to break some rules to get it. I figure that Portia knew she could help Bassanio, but was testing him, because she wanted to be sure he really had what it took to choose right. This would make sense, too, considering it's not the only time she tried to test him, there was also the time she tried to get him to break a promise to her. This is very interesting to me, because it seems to show that as much as she says she knows Bassanio is the one for her, perhaps she's not that sure, and feels she needs to make sure he's right for her.
Weekly ELA Blog Post #16
In the Merchant of Venice, the character Shylock recieves a harsh punishment for conspiring to murder a Venician citizen. As a modern reader, I find it hard to say his punishment, having to give away half his money to Antonio and promise the rest of it to his daughter upon death, should have been harsher or lighter. I'd say instead it seems it should have been different entirely. Ignoring the absurdity of the court deciding not to take its cut of his money and not to consider the death penalty, I just don't think the punishment was right. As bad as it all seems, Shylock really didn't do anything wrong in his eyes. Surely Antonio could have put something other than his own flesh up as collateral. Also, its clear the court was very biased against Shylock as a Jew. The way I see it, Elizabethian readers who happened to be anti-Semitic would say his punishment should have been harsher, but those who didn't hate Jewish people probably would have agreed the results of this court case were absurd. After all, this book was written to grab reader's attention and be interesting, not detail a real court case that the author thought was fair. I'd think that as a good author, he probably made the case in the story controversial because that would spark discussion about the book.
Weekly ELA Blog #15
I recently read Act 3 of The Merchant of Venice. In it, Shylock gave a short speech to prove Jews are equal to Christians. This seems odd, seeing as there was such strong anti-Semitism in Shakespeare's time. It seems, though, that this is not Shakespeare trying to make a case in defense of Jews. Rather, it seems he just meant to give the villain a good argument. I think he still meant for Shylock to be portrayed as the bad guy. However, he gave Shylock a strong argument because he didn't want one-dimensional characters. When charactets are "good" and "bad" with no motives, the story is often boring.
Friday, February 3, 2017
Weekly ELA Blog Post for week of 1/30
This week, our ELA class started reading Shakespeare's "The Merchant of Venice". There were a lot of interesting characters we were introduced to right off the bat in chapter 1, but the one that stood out to me the most was Portia, the maiden. In my opinion, it was very refreshing to see a woman standing up for herself in an old novel. It was especially interesting seeing as when we look at how Antonio treated Shylock, it seems Shakespeare wasn't afraid to include discrimination in his story. Therefore, the fact that he decided to have Portia actively try to discourage suitors was interesting. Of course, the fact that Bassanio says he loves her adds another interesting twist to the story. It seems like perhaps interactions between the two will later become central to the story. Either way, from her inclusion and role so far, it seems Portia will definitely be a character to follow as the story progresses.
Wednesday, December 14, 2016
Weekly ELA Blog Post #13
This week I will be blogging about a subject that really interested me in the Oddysey that I never got to write about before. That subject is the little blocks of italic text sprinkled throughout the book.
I didn't think much of these through most of the Oddysey, but when they became particularly prevalent in the last few books, I decided I'd like to look into them all a little more closely and figure out why they were there. What I noticed is this: all of them seemed to be similes or metaphors comparing the story's characters and their recent or current actions to other things. More specifically, though, they seemed to always be compared to animals, and always either a predator or a prey. In the case that characters did particularly noble, brave, or heroic things, they would almost always be compared to a predator chasing, killing, or gloating over its prey. On the other hand, if they were doing something cowardly or being killed, they were compared to prey being hunted, or in some cases herd animals being slaughtered.
I thought these little interjections made the story more interesting overall, and analyzing was overall very fun to do. That's all for this week.
I didn't think much of these through most of the Oddysey, but when they became particularly prevalent in the last few books, I decided I'd like to look into them all a little more closely and figure out why they were there. What I noticed is this: all of them seemed to be similes or metaphors comparing the story's characters and their recent or current actions to other things. More specifically, though, they seemed to always be compared to animals, and always either a predator or a prey. In the case that characters did particularly noble, brave, or heroic things, they would almost always be compared to a predator chasing, killing, or gloating over its prey. On the other hand, if they were doing something cowardly or being killed, they were compared to prey being hunted, or in some cases herd animals being slaughtered.
I thought these little interjections made the story more interesting overall, and analyzing was overall very fun to do. That's all for this week.
Tuesday, December 6, 2016
Weekly ELA Blog Post for the week of 12/5
My class has recently been reading "The Odyssey" by Homer. At the part we are at, the hero of the story, Odysseus, has just recently returned to his homeland that he is the king of after being away for 20 years. He is in disguise, however, so nobody knows he is back, and he is able to find out the opinions of the people he used to know without bias.
Two of these people in particular are his swineherd, Eumaeus, and his goatherd, Melanthius. Interestingly, their attitudes as a whole seem to be almost polar opposites. Eumaeus is very kind to Odysseus when he first arrives at Eumaeus's swine hut, and even though he believes that Oddyseus is just a poor beggar, he shows him much generosity, allowing him to sleep and eat in the swine hut for a few days before Telemachus orders take Oddyseus to the city to beg. On the other hand, Melanthius, who Odysseus runs into on his way in to town, is a rude and mean man who scorns Eumaues for even helping the beggar, and is even as bold as to kick Odysseus when he gets in the way. The other big difference between them is their attitude towards Oddyseus and his family in particular. Eumaues praises and reveres the family, and even shows his angst at Oddyseus being gone. Melanthius, on the other hand, jokes about Oddysseus having died at sea and expresses his hope that the suitors will kill Telemachus.
The question is, now that Oddyseus knows how both of these men feel about him, what will happen to them once Oddyseus takes back over his kingdom? I believe that Eumaues will probably recieve gifts and praise from Oddyseus. I don't think he'll be promoted from or relieved of his job as a swineherd, though, seeing as that's he's been doing his whole life. Plus, I can't think of any jobs it would make sense to promote him to. On the other hand, I think Melanthius's fate will be like his attitude: the opposite of Eumaues's. In fact, I believe that his punishment will be death, possibly a painful reason. There are a couple reasons I don't think he'll have a lighter punishment like demotion or exile. The first is how Oddyseus treated Irus. The only thing that kept him from killing Irus with one punch is that he didn't want to make the suitors suspicious. Plus, he did nothing to stop the horrible fate the suitors said they planned to exact on Irus, which included his genitals being mutilated. The second reason is that Oddyseus clearly has very few reserves about killing. Other than a single, ineffective warning to one suitor, there is no sign Oddyseus has any concerns with slaughtering all the suitors. The final reason, and probably the most significant one, is that, even though he managed to reserve himself in the end, Oddyseus seriously considered killing Melanthius on the spot on his way to his home.
This is what I believe will happen to Oddyseus's swineherd and goatherd soon because of what he learned about their attitudes. I'm assuming, though, that he will succeed in taking back Ithaca, but since he has Athena helping him, I'm pretty sure he will. Unless, of course, after the suitors are defeated, Telemachus turns on him and murders him. I have no idea why this would happen, but it sure would be interesting. That's all for this blog post, though. Adios.
Sunday, November 20, 2016
Weekly ELA Blog Post #11
In this weekly blog post, I'm going to compare the hospitality Telemachus received in his travels to the hospitality Odysseus received from the Phaeacians. One way the hospitality they recieved is similar is that they were both told stories about the Trojan War. However, Telemachus heard the stories through simple spoken word, while Odysseus heard them in song from a bard. Another big difference is that Oddyseus arrived alone and in poor condition, so he was cleaned up, while Telemachus didn't have to be because he arrived on a boat with a crew. Another way they were similar is that they were both invited to big feasts. Finally, one last difference is the entertainment Odysseus recieved. He got to watch the Phaeacians play sports and dance, in order to give him good things to tell people back at home. Plus, he was challenged to sports by a Phaeacian. All in all, both father and son were treated very well by their hosts, and recieved great hospitality.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)